Mystery Celeb Extortion Case, YoungBoy Plea Deal, Whitney Houston Movie & More Legal News

This is The Legal Beat, a weekly newsletter about music law from Billboard Pro, offering you a one-stop cheat sheet of big new cases, important rulings and all the fun stuff in between.

This week: A lawyer repping alleged Diddy victims is accused of extorting settlements out of “innocent celebrities” by linking them to the rapper; NBA YoungBoy reaches a plea deal to resolve prescription drug charges; Sony settles a copyright lawsuit over Whitney Houston’s biopic; and much more.

THE BIG STORY: Mystery Celeb Sues Diddy Crusader For Extortion

Back in October, shortly after Houston attorney Tony Buzbee announced that he’d be filing a torrent of abuse litigation against Sean “Diddy” Combs, he gave an interview to TMZ warning that he was also planning to sue other celebrities who had “allowed it to go on” and “said nothing” about the alleged abuse: “All of these individuals and entities in my view have exposure here,” he said.

During the same interview, Buzbee confirmed that he’d already been sending legal demand letters to those high-profile individuals and that some had quickly inked settlements to avoid lawsuits and keep their names private. In a clip from the TMZ newsroom discussing the interview, one staffer said: “It just feels like a money grab!”

Now, it turns out that sentiment is shared by one of the celebrities Buzbee is targeting.

In a lawsuit filed Monday (Nov. 18) in Los Angeles, an unnamed “John Doe” celebrity accused Buzbee of extortion, claiming the attorney was threatening to unleash “wildly false horrific allegations” if they weren’t sufficiently paid off. Repped by a legal team from the white shoe law firm Quinn Emanuel, the mysterious “public figure” called Buzbee’s efforts a “cynical extortion scheme” aimed at “innocent celebrities” who have “any ties to Combs — no matter how remote.”

The case raises uncomfortable questions about the American legal system. Are threats of civil litigation and demands for settlement simply a cost-effective way for attorneys to seek justice for victims? Or are they tantamount to legalized blackmail, exploiting the publicity surrounding lawsuits and the risk of reputational ruin to coerce unearned payouts?

To Buzbee, who immediately announced that he would move forward with his lawsuit against the mystery celeb, it’s clearly the former: “It is obvious that the frivolous lawsuit filed against my firm is an aggressive attempt to intimidate or silence me and ultimately my clients,” he said in a statement following the filing of the extortion case. “That effort is a gross miscalculation.”

Other top stories this week…

MORE DIDDY NEWS – Prosecutors accused the disgraced rapper of seeking to “subvert the integrity” of his sex trafficking case from jail, including by contacting witnesses and orchestrating “social media campaigns” to influence public opinion and taint the jury pool. The star’s lawyers quickly fired back, claiming prosecutors had obtained their evidence by improperly searching his cell and violated his right to attorney-client privilege — actions they called “outrageous government conduct.”

LIL DURK UPDATE – Represented by a prominent new criminal defense attorney, Lil Durk pleaded not guilty to federal murder-for-hire charges over an alleged plot to kill rival rapper Quando Rondo in a 2022 shooting. At the same arraignment hearing, the judge also set a tentative trial date for early January, but that schedule could (and very likely will) be moved back as the case proceeds.

PLEA DEAL – Rapper NBA YoungBoy pleaded guilty to his role in a large-scale prescription drug fraud ring that operated out of his multimillion-dollar home in Utah — a location where he was already serving under house arrest stemming from earlier gun charges. The deal came with a 27-month prison sentence, but the penalty was suspended pending the resolution of YoungBoy’s firearms case.

METAL SETTLEMENT – Megadeth and lead singer Dave Mustaine agreed to pay $1.4 million to resolve allegations that they still owed commissions to Cory Brennan, a longtime manager who says he was “unceremoniously” fired and replaced by Mustaine’s son. But the deal will not resolve Mustaine’s countersuit, in which he claims that Brennan’s “repeated management failures” caused him serious harm.

“REAL LOVE” RESPONSE – Universal Music Group (UMG)asked a federal judge to dismiss a copyright lawsuit claiming Mary J. Blige’s 1992 hit “Real Love” sampled from “Impeach the President” by the Honey Drippers — a legendary piece of hip-hop source material used by Run-DMC, Dr. Dre and others. UMG argued that the accuser (Tuff City Records) popped up “out of the blue” decades later to sue over two tracks that “sound nothing alike.”

YE SUED YET AGAIN – The rapper (formerly Kanye West) was hit with a lawsuit over Vultures 1 from a group of Memphis rappers who claim the star and Ty Dolla $ign committed “brazen” copyright infringement by sampling from a 1994 song called “Drink a Yak (Part 2)” even after failing to secure a license. The new case is just one of more than a dozen that have been filed against Ye over claims of unlicensed sampling or interpolating during his prolific career.

WHITNEY CASE CLOSED – Sony Music reached an undisclosed settlement to end a lawsuit claiming the producers of the 2022 Whitney Houston biopic (Whitney Houston: I Wanna Dance With Somebody) never fully paid to use her songs, including “I Will Always Love You” and “I’m Every Woman.” The case, filed in February, said such licenses were particularly valuable in the context of musical biopics: “It is nearly impossible to explain the importance of a musician’s creative genius or unique style and talent without the use of the musician’s music.”